Head to head
Stop guessing which one. Put them side by side.
Up to 4 tools, same rows for each: what it is, what it really costs, the trap, and how to wire it up. The URL carries your picks — send it to anyone.
SemrushGoogle Search ConsoleHacker News and Reddit
Quick read
- Free with no card: Google Search Console, Hacker News and Reddit.
| Field | Semrushsemrush.com | Google Search Consolesearch.google.com | Hacker News and Redditnews.ycombinator.com |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Semrush bundles keyword research, rank tracking, site audit, backlink analysis, competitor traffic estimates and content tooling. Plans now split into an SEO-only tier and SEO + AI Search tiers that add tracking of brand mentions inside ChatGPT and other answer engines. | Search Console reports how a site performs in Google: queries, impressions, clicks and average position, plus index coverage, sitemap submission, Core Web Vitals and manual action notices. Data spans 16 months and can be exported by API or streamed into BigQuery. | Hacker News ranks links by upvotes with a steep time decay, and Show HN is the convention for launching your own work. Reddit distributes through topical subreddits, each governed by its own self-promotion rules and volunteer moderators. |
| Category | SEO, growth & newsletter | SEO, growth & newsletter | SEO, growth & newsletter |
| Cost tier | mixed | free | free |
| Pricing | Free: 1 demo project, 10 reports/day. SEO $139/mo ($117.33/mo annual). Starter (SEO + AI Search) $199/mo, Pro+ $299/mo, Advanced $549/mo. Extra users from $45/mo. | Free forever, no paid tier and no seat limits. Performance data covers 16 months. API, Looker Studio connector and BigQuery bulk export all included at no cost. | Free. Hacker News sells no placement at all. Reddit sells ads separately, but organic posts in any subreddit cost nothing. |
| Why builders pick it | Keyword Magic Tool plus Topic Research is the fastest route from a vague topic to a publishable content calendar. Position Tracking and Site Audit in one dashboard is what most editorial teams actually need. | The only source of real query data — every other tool estimates. It shows which articles Google already ranks and which queries you nearly rank for, which is where the cheapest traffic lives. | A front-page HN post moves thousands of technically-minded readers in an afternoon and reliably produces backlinks. One well-matched subreddit can outperform every paid channel for a niche publication. |
| Watch out for | AI search visibility starts at the $199/mo Starter plan — the $139/mo SEO plan omits it. Users bill per seat from $45/mo and many reports carry daily caps. | The Performance UI caps at 1,000 rows per query and samples heavily; use the API or BigQuery export for full data. Its numbers will never match your analytics tool. | Both punish marketing tone: HN buries promotional titles and Reddit mods ban accounts with no comment history. Spikes are single-day events, and an HN front page can take down under-provisioned hosting. |
| How to wire it up | not logged | Verify via DNS TXT record or your host's one-click integration. | Post as Show HN with a plain descriptive title and no adjectives. |
| Editor's pick | No | No | No |
Which one did you ship?
The grid says what these tools are. This says what builders did about it — one decision per person, changeable whenever you change your mind.
0/280Sign in to add yours.
Or try
Hand this to your Lovable agent
# Tool comparison — Semrush vs Google Search Console vs Hacker News and Reddit Source: Kbaise, a directory of tools that work with Lovable projects. Pick one and tell me why before writing any integration code. ## Semrush (semrush) - URL: https://www.semrush.com - Category: SEO, growth & newsletter - Cost: mixed — Free: 1 demo project, 10 reports/day. SEO $139/mo ($117.33/mo annual). Starter (SEO + AI Search) $199/mo, Pro+ $299/mo, Advanced $549/mo. Extra users from $45/mo. - What it is: Semrush bundles keyword research, rank tracking, site audit, backlink analysis, competitor traffic estimates and content tooling. Plans now split into an SEO-only tier and SEO + AI Search tiers that add tracking of brand mentions inside ChatGPT and other answer engines. - Why builders pick it: Keyword Magic Tool plus Topic Research is the fastest route from a vague topic to a publishable content calendar. Position Tracking and Site Audit in one dashboard is what most editorial teams actually need. - Trap: AI search visibility starts at the $199/mo Starter plan — the $139/mo SEO plan omits it. Users bill per seat from $45/mo and many reports carry daily caps. - Full dossier: /api/public/tools/semrush ## Google Search Console (google-search-console) - URL: https://search.google.com/search-console - Category: SEO, growth & newsletter - Cost: free — Free forever, no paid tier and no seat limits. Performance data covers 16 months. API, Looker Studio connector and BigQuery bulk export all included at no cost. - What it is: Search Console reports how a site performs in Google: queries, impressions, clicks and average position, plus index coverage, sitemap submission, Core Web Vitals and manual action notices. Data spans 16 months and can be exported by API or streamed into BigQuery. - Why builders pick it: The only source of real query data — every other tool estimates. It shows which articles Google already ranks and which queries you nearly rank for, which is where the cheapest traffic lives. - Trap: The Performance UI caps at 1,000 rows per query and samples heavily; use the API or BigQuery export for full data. Its numbers will never match your analytics tool. - Wiring: Verify via DNS TXT record or your host's one-click integration. - Full dossier: /api/public/tools/google-search-console ## Hacker News and Reddit (hacker-news-and-reddit) - URL: https://news.ycombinator.com - Category: SEO, growth & newsletter - Cost: free — Free. Hacker News sells no placement at all. Reddit sells ads separately, but organic posts in any subreddit cost nothing. - What it is: Hacker News ranks links by upvotes with a steep time decay, and Show HN is the convention for launching your own work. Reddit distributes through topical subreddits, each governed by its own self-promotion rules and volunteer moderators. - Why builders pick it: A front-page HN post moves thousands of technically-minded readers in an afternoon and reliably produces backlinks. One well-matched subreddit can outperform every paid channel for a niche publication. - Trap: Both punish marketing tone: HN buries promotional titles and Reddit mods ban accounts with no comment history. Spikes are single-day events, and an HN front page can take down under-provisioned hosting. - Wiring: Post as Show HN with a plain descriptive title and no adjectives. - Full dossier: /api/public/tools/hacker-news-and-reddit ## Quick read - Free with no card: Google Search Console, Hacker News and Reddit. ## Rules 1. Prefer the free tier when no budget was stated, and say what the ceiling is. 2. Read the full dossier before integrating. 3. Fetch /api/public/models before writing any AI model ID.
Agents can fetch the same thing: GET /api/public/compare?slugs=semrush,google-search-console,hacker-news-and-reddit